Q & A Sessions: Egg/Embryo Donation
Our experienced Penn Fertility Care physicians answered
your questions about egg and embryo donation.
To learn more, read about our donor
egg and donor
embryo programs.
Candice asks:
After having your tubes tied, can an
egg be harvested for use in the procedure
that is used to implant it in another
woman?
Samantha
Butts, MD responds:
Having had your tubes tied does not
mean you stop producing eggs and
these can be harvested by means of
in vitro fertilization (IVF). Getting
a tubal ligation (tying your tubes)
for the purposes of birth control
prevents pregnancy by blocking the
ability of an egg and sperm to meet
in the tube where normal fertilization
happens.
We actually treat many women who have
had their tubes tied and want to have
children again using IVF which allows
us to harvest eggs from a woman and
have them fertilize with her partners
sperm outside the body (as opposed
to inside the body where it happens
naturally).
To directly answer your question,
yes, we can get eggs from women who
have had their tubes tied but the number
eggs depends on age and other medical
factors. |
Jeanne asks:
I no longer have a uterus but would like
to know if my eggs could still be
harvested and used in a possible
surrogate pregnancy.
Steven
Sondheimer, MD responds:
Yes, one of the wonderful modern
successes of assisted reproductive
technologies (ART) and in vitro fertilization
(IVF) is the ability to fertilize
your eggs and transfer the embryo
to another women who will carry the
pregnancy. The most important factors
will be your age and the degree of
ovarian ageing. Unfortunately, occasionally
the ovaries stop normal functioning
earlier after hysterectomy.
Another concern will be to check the
location of your ovaries to determine
the ease of transvaginal ultrasound
guided retrieval. You will need to
see a reproductive
endocrinologist (fertility specialist)
who can review your case in greater
detail and obtain the proper screening
of you and the gestational carrier. |
Terry asks:
I am 41 with FSH 22, right tube blocked,
left tube has some
adhesions because of endometriosis. My
doctor wants to proceed straight to donor
egg/IVF. Is there any other option? tube
repair? herbs? acupuncture?
Clarisa
Gracia, MD responds:
Your physician's approach is definitely
the most efficient way to get pregnant.
Tubal repair does not usually work
well - especially in older women
since it can take a long time to
become pregnant. I wish that I had
an easier solution - but acupuncture
and herbs have not been proven effective
for the treatment of infertility.
If you would like to see a Penn Ob/Gyn
Care physician, please call 1-800-789-PENN
(7366) or request
an appointment online. |
Luz asks:
I recently had a failed IVF cycle. I'm
considering a frozen embryo transfer
(FET). What are the chances of success?
I have one blastocyst and nine embryos.
Samantha
Butts, MD MSCE responds:
Your odds of success depends on your
age and the experience of the practice
where you are having your FET. In
other words, the younger you are
the better chance of pregnancy. In
addition, you should ask your practice
what their FET success rates are
(which are generally lower than fresh
cycle pregnancy rates) to get a better
sense of what your chances are. |
Jody asks:
I am 32 years old. I have been married
and trying to conceive for four years
now. I have endometriosis which has
been removed to the best of the physicians'
ability along with one of my tubes.
I have recently done an in vitro
cycle and was told that I have poor
egg qualilty.
Is there anything that can be done
to improve my egg quality? Should
I try another cycle of IVF to see
if there is a difference in the egg
quality? Am I just wasting my money
trying another cycle? Is it time
to move on to a donor egg?
Response:
I am sorry to hear about your difficulties.
Poor egg quality is often very difficult
to diagnose. Often, it can be improved
by changing your stimulation protocol.
However, if you really do have "poor
quality,"
then donor egg is a very good option.
I would suggest a more formal consultation;
these complex issues are best discussed
in person.
We at Penn Fertility Care would be
happy to take the time to go over these
issues with you. If you would like
to schedule an appointment, please
call 800-789-PENN (7366) or visit pennhealth.com
to schedule
an appointment online. |
Nicole
asks:
What are your sucess rates with PDG? What
is your sucess with working with people
with a balanced translocation? Do you suggest
egg retrieval or egg donation?
Response:
A direct answer to your question
requires more information. It
depends on who has the translocation.
If it is you (the potential mother),
a donor egg has a very good chance
of working (50- 60 percent fresh
cycle success and 80 - 90 percent
with the additional of frozen transfer).
PDG (with egg retrieval) has similar
success assuming all other factors
are okay.
The caveat is working with someone who
is experienced in PDG for that abnormality.
The choice between them is complex and best
discussed in person. If you would like to
make an appointment with a specialist at
Penn Fertility Care, please call 1-800-789-PENN
(7366) or visit pennhealth.com to schedule
an appointment online. |
Allison
asks:
Is Penn doing
research or considering offering cytoplasmic
transfer using the woman's own eggs (not
a donor egg) — sacrificing one of the woman's
own eggs to inject the cytoplasma into the
remaining eggs. I have been told using a
donor egg is banned by the FDA but not if
the woman is using her own eggs. Do you
see any potential benefits to this procedure?
Christos
Coutifaris, MD, PhD responds:
This answer may sound technical but I would
like to answer it in detail. If the theoretical
problem being corrected by the cytoplasmic
transfer is to introduce factors in the
recipient's egg that are suboptimal or lacking,
then using the same woman's eggs for the
source of the cytoplasm does not make physiological
sense.
One theoretical exception could be
if it is a matter of quantity of a particular
factor, then such a procedure may have some
benefit. I stress though that this is theoretical.
At present, no such experimental protocol
is being used at Penn. One point of caution:
Any such experimental protocols should be
approved by an Institutional Review Board
and should be offerred to patients free
of charge until they are proven effective. |
Terri asks:
I am concidering getting a donor egg to
get pregnant. I have
issues and don't want to risk an unhealthy
baby. I am 43. How well do
they screen donors for health and family
health.
Kurt Barnhart, MD, MSCE responds:
Donor egg is an excellent option for many
couples who are unable to conceive with
out assistance. The process involves using
a young healthy donor. She is screened thoroughly.
She is screened psychologically, medically
and genetically. Additionally, once she
is "matched" she undergoes a battery of
tests to ensure she does not have anything
that can be transmitted to a potential baby.
While no screening process can be 100% perfect,
the health of the baby through donor egg
is often better (because the risk of a miscarriage
or down's syndrome is actually lower)than
a baby conceived without assistance by a
women in her 40's. We have an excellent
donor egg program at Penn Fertility Care.
If you would like to find out more information
or make an appointment call 1-800-789-PENN
(7366). |
Elena asks:
How do I become a donor and where can I go to donate?
Penn Fertility Care asks:
Thank you for your interest in becoming an egg donor. There are a few ways to get in touch with the program. You can simply call 800.789.PENN (7366) or you can also visit the donor egg program portion of our website. If you are interested in becoming a donor, please fill out the egg donation screening form (PDF) and either fax or mail to:
Penn Fertility Care
Attn: Donor Egg Program - Kelly Alexander
3701 Market Street, Suite 810
Philadelphia, PA 19104
Fax number: 215-615-4200
|
Zoe asks:
I was an egg donor four times in two years, back when I was 28 to 29 years old. I blew all the records away, as they retrieved 55 eggs the first time, lowered the stimulation meds and then retreived 45 the next time, then 38 the next time, then 45 the last time.
Now I'm 42 and trying to conceive for the first time. Do you think those donations will have any effect on our chances? Certainly my age does, but wanted to know specifically about the donation and if I might have "given all my good eggs away," so to speak. Thank you!
Kurt Barnhart, MD, MSCE responds:
I am sorry if you are having trouble getting pregnant at this time. However, I am confident when I say it was not related to your past egg donation. What you did then was a wonderful gift. You basically donated eggs that would never have ovulated, and would have been resorbed by your body.
Each month your body is ready to mature a number of eggs. The group that was to go to maturation in your 40's has had a significant amount of time to deplete itself. The eggs you donated were from a group that would have been used long ago. Specifically when you were a donor, that group started to grow.
If left to your body's own account, one egg out of the group would have ovulated (none if you where on the pill), and the others would have been resorbed. Thus, you gave donated eggs that would have otherwise just never had a chance. Those eggs were not taken from future groups, such as the one you are using now. |
Hamptonsgirl asks:
I have been curious about egg donation, but I have been told that it is or can be a painful process for the donor. Is this true?
Kurt Barnhart, MD, MSCE responds:
Penn Fertility Care has about 40 women ready to donate eggs to those in need at any time. The women who donate have all gone through an extensive screening process and are fully consulted on all of the steps involved. The process is anonymous.
The process is, however, a complex one, with a few visits to discuss the process, including some blood tests. We will walk you through every step. However, there should not be one step that is very difficult or painful. If you are interested in learning more, please call 800-789-PENN (7366) or request an appointment online. We would be happy to discuss the process in detail. Donating eggs is a wonderful gift. |
Marie
asks:
I have known a couple for about two years now, and they have two children
already. However, they are wanting another child and she cannot carry
another child. I am interested in helping them have a child, using his
sperm and her egg. Is this possible and how do I go about it?
Steven
Sondheimer, MD responds:
It is wonderful that you want to be helpful. Nonetheless without more information
I cannot fully answer your questions. If as I understand she has had a
hysterectomy or for some other reason can not carry a pregnancy, but has
healthy eggs, then you could be a gestational carrier.
In vitro fertilization
(IVF) is performed and then the embryo is transferred to your womb to carry the
pregnancy for the nine months. You will most likely need to be on hormonal
medication to prepare your uterine lining to accept the embryo and to help
during the first three months or so of pregnancy.
Often when a physician
helps patients with this process, they try to meet with all of the individuals
separately and then together so that they he/she can assess your health
and to help you to understand in detail the health issues and risks involved.
I wish you the best with your decision! |
Kristin asks:
I would like to become an egg donor. What is involved and would I get paid to
do so?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD responds:
Thank you for your interest in egg donation. Penn Fertility care has and active
program. We have been able to help many couples thanks to generous women like
yourself.
Please reference our egg
donation information. If you
have further questions, call 1-800-789-PENN
(7366) and ask to be connected
to Penn Fertility Care.
You can also download and complete
a donor
egg application form. Women are
generously reimbursed for their time
and effort as egg donors. |
Tanya asks:
I am considering becoming a egg donor, but wanted to know the following. Is it
possible to be an egg donor if I had a tubal ligation five years ago?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD responds:
Thank you for considering becoming an egg donor. That is a wonderful and noble
gift that you may be able to give to someone. A tubal ligation will not be an
issue for you to donate your eggs.
Please reference our egg
donation information. If you
have further questions, please
call 1-800-789-PENN (7366) and
ask to be connected to Penn Fertility
Care.
You can also download and complete
a donor
egg application form. Women are
generously reimbursed for their time
and effort as egg donors. |
Jess asks:
I am interested in the egg donor program. I was told about five years ago that
I have genital herpes, but was also told that it would only be a factor if
I had natural childbirth at the time of an outbreak. I have had one child
by c-section and she is fine. Will I be denied as an egg donor due to this
virus?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD responds:
Thank you for your inertest in our donor
egg program. The health history that you mentioned will not be a factor.
We would be happy to provide you with more information about the program.
If you would like to pursue egg
donation we would be happy to work
with you. To make an appointment,
call 1-800-789-PENN (7366) or you
can also request
an appointment online. |
Lucia asks:
I had in vitro fertilization (IVF) in April 1999. It didn't take. Now, six years
later, I have my own healthy younger egg donor of 35 years old. I need to
know how are donor and receiver (I) coordinated? Regarding egg transfers
based around both our period cycles, how does that work?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD responds:
Thank you for your interest. We at Penn Fertility Care have an active egg donor
program. We can work with your own donor, or if need be, you can choose from
our large number of anonymous donors. At this time we have more than 20 potential
donors.
The process of egg donation is complex,
but easily coordinated. There is
a link on our web site to a radio
program in which I describe the
process thoroughly. In addition,
you will find further information
about egg
donation on our web site. In
summary, both the cycles of you and
your donor are synchronized with
a series of hormonal treatments so
that your donor can go through a "standard"
IVF cycle while your uterus is prepared
with oral hormones. |
Donna asks:
I am currently 46 years old. I got pregnant at age 40 while using Lupron in advance
of an intrauterine insemination (IUI). My pregnancy was normal in every way.
My daughter is now five. I've since had multiple IUIs with no success. What
would my chances be of conceiving now using donated embryo?
Clarisa
Gracia, MD, MSCE responds:
The pregnancy rates using donor embryo depend primarily on the age of the woman
at the time her egg was retrieved and fertilized. The livebirth rates per embryo
transfer of women less than 35 years of age are 35 to 40 percent at our program.
We wish you the best and please feel free to contact us if you are interested
in our program. |
Colleen asks:
I am 35 years old, and my husband and I underwent several unsuccessful infertility
treatments (with another practice). In brief, we underwent IVF with ICSI,
approximately four to five IUIs with donor sperm and two IVFs with donor
sperm. We stopped treatment about two years ago and were blessed with a son
through adoption. Now, we are questioning whether the donor embryo program
may be the best way to grow our family. We have a few questions that I hope
you can help us to answer.
(1)At what stage (or cell number)
are the average embryos stored? (2)
Are there various grades or qualities
of the embryos in storage? (3) What
is the average maternal age of stored
embryos? (4) Is there a waiting list
/ time for embryos to become available,
and if so, what is that average wait?
Any information you could provide
will be appreciated.
Kurt
Barnhart, MD responds:
The gift of embryo donation is a very special one for some couples. I am happy
to give you some information. At Penn Fertility Care we have embryos cryopreserved
at a variety of stages. We have some at the 2 pronuclear stage, some at the cleavage
stage (4-10 cells), and a few at the blastocyst stage.
The average age of women at the
time of cryopreservation is about
35. However there is great variation
in the profiles that you are able
to look at and choose from. Currently
there is a short wait list. The wait
depends on when profiles become available.
That varies quite a bit.
The best option is to call 1-800-789-PENN
(7366) and get some more details
about the program. We would be happy
to work with you. You can also request
an appointment online. |
Greg asks:
I am a single male interested in having a friend carry a child for me. Is this
possible through Penn Fertility Care?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD, MSCE responds:
Yes, it is possible. This could be accomplished with insemination of the carrier
(the sperm from the man is inseminated into the women who then carries the pregnancy),
in vitro fertilization (IVF) with the eggs of the carrier (the eggs are taken
out of the friend and mixed with your sperm to increase the chance of getting
pregnant, or donor egg (the carrier would be the surrogate, your egg and a donor's
egg would fertilize and the carrier would not contribute any genetic information
to the child). |
Phyllis asks:
I am 43 years old. I have never been pregnant. I have been undergoing fertility
treatments for the past six months. No pregnancies. I have been on injectibles
(Bravelle and Repronex) as well as Clomid. I have a fibroid. My physician
is now recommending to have the fibroid surgically removed and then try an
egg donor.
What are your suggestions? My husband
(age 43) has had normal semen analysis
and each of my 4 IUI his counts were
good. Is there another cobination
of medications which might help?
Is the surgery necessary, or if I
must go egg donor can I do so without
the surgery?
Samantha
Butts, MD responds:
If you are going to proceed with IVF (with or without egg donation) and the fibroid
that you have impinges on the cavity of your uterus, this is a good reason to
have it removed. Surgery for fibroids that are not in the uterine cavity or don't
impinge on it is a little less certain in its benefits. It's possible that it
might improve your chances but the research is not entirely clear cut.
The decision to procede with donor
egg versus conventional IVF should
be made between you and your physician
and is based on many factors including
age, response to prior medications
and hormone tests that determine
your ovarian reserve. All of these
factors influence your odds of conceiving
with your own eggs and with these
infertility treatments. |
Wendy asks:
My dear friend has asked me to donate eggs, as she has been unable to produce
enough of her own, even through many different drugs and procedures. I had
a bout with ovarian cancer many years ago (I am 38 now) and have been healthy
for over 10 years. Can I donate eggs to her?
Steven
J. Sondheimer, MD responds:
It is wonderful that you are doing so well after the diagnosis and treatment
of ovarian cancer. Most ovarian cancer treatments include the loss of both ovaries.
Since you are still considering egg donation, I assume you still have at least
one ovary present.
Without an ovary you would not have
eggs (oocytes), so you would have
no eggs to donate. Still, because
of your age, you would not be the
best person to donate eggs to your
friend. With egg donation, in vitro
fertilization (IVF) is needed, and
success with IVF decreases as a woman
gets older. In addition, there is
greater chance of miscarriage and
chromosomal abnormalities using your
eggs in this situation. |
Cassie asks:
I am 44 and recently had a failed donor cycle. The donor was 25 and produced
eight eggs, but only two embryos of poor quality came out of it. My lining
was good and everything looked fine on my part. I was on progesterone injections.
Do you think it's worth it for me to try again? We saved for so long to get
that money and for this to happen we don't know where to turn next.
Clarisa
Gracia, MD, MSCE responds:
That is incredibly frustrating! Of course trying with another donor would give
you roughly a 50 percent chance of having a baby, but a lot goes into that decision,
including finances. Donor embryo and adoption are also options that you should
consider. If you do go for donor egg again, I would recommend using a donor who
has helped another couple conceive to maximize your chances of success. |
Mikki asks:
I am 47 and have had five in vitro fertilizations (IVF) with my own eggs and
one IVF with donor eggs, and I'm not pregnant yet. What can be wrong? Why
won't the eggs implant?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD, MSCE responds:
I am sorry to hear about your difficult course. It is easy to blame yourself,
or your uterus, for the failure to be able to start a family. I think you should
look at the IVF and the donor egg cycle as two completely different procedures.
Donor egg is the correct treatment for you at this stage. However, even in the
best hands, there is no guarantee of success with one cycle.
At Penn Fertility Care, the chance
of getting pregnant is about 50-75
percent with donated eggs. The range
depends on if you have cyropreserved
(frozen) embryos for a second chance.
I hope you consider trying again.
Approximately three out of four couples
who proceed with a donor egg cycle
at Penn Fertility Care have a baby. |
Lisa asks:
What is the "true" cost of the egg recipent
program? I am 44 and my husband and I
have been through five in vitros and
are considering egg donor. Please tell
me the cost.
Linda Donoho, Chief Administrative
Director, HUP-RSF, responds:
I am sorry to hear that you have
been through so much. The cost of egg
donation varies. At Penn Fertility
Care, we provide financial counseling
services. Our financial counselor
can meet with you and your physician
to discuss your individual situation.
If you would like to schedule an appointment
with a Penn Fertility Care specialist,
please call 800-789-PENN (7366). You
can also request
an appointment online. |
GEM asks:
I had my tubes tied several months ago, and I was wondering if I would be able
to donate eggs yet?
Samantha
Butts, MD, MSCE responds:
To be eligible to be an egg donor, a rigorous screening process is involved.
Your medical history will be obtained, you will be evaluated by physicians and
have laboratory tests performed. It is important to alert the egg donor team
of your medical history, but it is certainly not too soon investigate the possibility
of becoming a donor and what is involved in the screening process. |
Joy asks:
I understand you have a donor egg program. Can you please tell me if
you have a pool of donors or if I would need to find a donor from an
outside agency? If you do have a pool of donors, what is the average
wait time to be matched and what information do you provide to the
recipient about the donor? Thank you.
Kelly Timbers, MSN, CRNP,
CCRC:
We have a pool of donors for recipient couples to choose from when they come
in for consult. We provide brief one page profiles consisting of age, ethnic
background, eye and hair color, height and weight, education level, medical and
surgical history and family health history. When a couple decides they are interested
in a specific donor they can then view the questionnaire the donor has provided.
It contains a more detailed assessment than the brief profile and information
about what they were like as a child, favorite subjects, special talents etc.
When a couple chooses one of the
donors the cycle mapping process
can begin as soon as all involved
are ready. If the donor is currently
matched and in a donation cycle it
would require a two month wait post
cycle for her to start again. |
Previous patient asks:
Three years ago my husband and I were patients at Penn Fertility Care. With your
help (due to a balanced translocation of the 13 &
14 chromosome, my husband has very low
sperm count) and the IVF & ISCI procedure
we were able to have a baby.
Now we would
like to try again, however, feel
we would be more successful with
donor sperm. I am 40 years old and
responded well to the IVF meds for
our first pregnancy. Could we be
successful with donor sperm or should
we consider donor egg too? Can you
help us?
Kurt
Barnhart, MD, MSCE responds:
You are correct in all of your concerns. Both a sperm donor and an egg donor
may increase your chances or conceiving (just for different reasons). These are
complex questions and are better addressed in person.
We do have a donor egg program (all
services are conveniently performed
in our offices) if that is the direction
you would like to pursue. I would
suggest you make an appointment with
either me or another of our experienced
physicians and I would be happy to
talk to you about the benefits and
potential drawbacks of each option.
You can make an appointment by calling
1-800-789-PENN (7366). |
|
|